In the manner of
David Hume

Section I. Of the Method to Be Observed
All the objects of human reason may be divided into two kinds: relations of ideas, and matters of fact. That two and two make four is of the first kind, and may be known by thought alone. That Melissa and Jimmy ought to marry is of the second, and can be known, if at all, only by experience. I attempt no demonstration, therefore; I lay the facts before the reader, and leave him to judge.
Section II. Of Contiguity
Contiguity in place is one of the principles by which ideas are associated, and the vulgar suppose it equally powerful among persons. The present case does not support them. Melissa, a native of Draguignan in the Var, made her home in London for twelve years. Jimmy, an Indianapolis man, passed some eighteen months there as a student. For a time the same city contained them both, and they never met. From which we learn that nearness, of itself, produces nothing.
Section III. Of Chance, and of the Testimony of Witnesses
They met instead in New York, at Le Poisson Rouge, a house of music, on an evening given over to the songs of the 1980s, through a mutual friend. Melissa was then a visitor to the city, her residence being still in London. Those fond of discovering design in nature will look for a contriver; but the mutual friend contrived nothing beyond an introduction, and the argument from design, as usual, proves more than the evidence allows.
Is it then to be called chance? Chance is nothing real in itself, but merely the name we give to our ignorance of causes. What followed that evening has not been of the kind usually produced by luck.
Of the evening itself two witnesses survive, and their testimony is not of equal force. Our ideas are only the fainter copies of our impressions. Melissa retains of that night something very like the original impression; Jimmy retains rather an idea of it, lively in places and faint in others, as ideas are apt to be. Where such witnesses differ, a prudent judge follows the one who remembers.
Section IV. Of a Record Kept by Experiment
Memory is a poor archive. Jimmy, to his credit as an experimental philosopher, has kept since 2019 a register of the concerts he attends. The register begins too late to include the evening of the eighties songs. But Melissa’s first entry in it is, by a pleasing return, a later concert at the same Le Poisson Rouge; her name has since been entered upon it above forty times, and few names now stand higher. Here at last is what the philosopher most desires: not one striking instance, but a constant conjunction, written down.
Section V. Of the Separation of Persons by Oceans
In 2020 and 2021 America refused Melissa entry, and the crossings to London were therefore all Jimmy’s, in aeroplanes so thinly peopled that the passengers might have been counted without any great exertion of arithmetic. A journey made once proves curiosity. A journey made over and over proves something else.
Section VI. Of the Uniformity of Nature, as Tried in Iceland
In the summer of 2021 Iceland alone, of all the nations, would receive them both, and there they met. One night they lingered over live music till two o’clock, and came out into broad day.
No man sees the evening close at its hour a thousand times without expecting it on the thousand and first. Yet this expectation is founded on custom alone, and not on reason: that the sun will not set is no less intelligible a proposition, and implies no more contradiction, than that it will. I had not expected the experiment to be performed after a concert, but there it stood: two persons, every habit of their understanding assuring them it was night, and the sky declining to agree.
By the autumn Melissa had removed to New York. An ocean, it appears, is an inconvenience, and not a principle.
Section VII. Of Custom, as Observed at the Card Table
Custom is the great guide of human life. It teaches us to expect the dark at evening, and teaches a family which card game is the natural one. In Jimmy’s family the game, time out of mind, is Euchre, which the American Midwest regards as its own; in Melissa’s it is Belote. Melissa holds the former to be an easier species of the latter, which is exactly the judgement custom passes on the customs of others.
At one sitting, opposed to Jimmy’s parents, Melissa contested a hand. Jimmy’s brother was appointed arbiter, and the parties were described to him without their names, that his judgement might be impartial. The precaution was vain: the arbiter knew the parties as well as he knew his own hand, and found against Melissa. The experiment shows that names may be withheld from a judge a great deal more easily than knowledge.
Section VIII. Of Miracles
A miracle is a violation of the laws of nature, and no testimony suffices to establish one unless its falsehood would be more miraculous than the fact. Let us try the following by that rule.
Before proposing, Jimmy sought the blessing of Melissa’s parents by video call. He asked it in French, or in something that stood to French as an approximate copy stands to its original, consulting, out of sight of the camera, a paper on which he had set down, against various contingencies, such expressions as he judged might serve. He spoke; they answered, with great emphasis, yes. Jimmy came away triumphant. He had made himself understood, in a foreign tongue, upon the most delicate question a man can put to two parents.
It was afterwards discovered that his hearers had followed none of it. They had observed, upon their screen, a young man plainly in earnest, asking something of consequence, and guessed the rest. The discovery lowered him considerably in his own esteem. His meaning was never conveyed by his words, but, like all our knowledge of matters of fact, by inference from effect to cause. Here, then, is the only miracle I am disposed to admit: a question answered correctly by persons who could not follow it. And even this, upon examination, proves no violation of the laws of nature, but a very pretty instance of them.
Section IX. Of the Passions, and Their Government in Cellars
Reason is, and ought only to be, the slave of the passions. Here is an instance which seems at first to contradict it.
In July 2024 they were travelling in France, and in the Champagne country were joined by the friend of Melissa’s earliest years and her husband, whose daughter Jimmy and Melissa had not met before. Jimmy pleaded an appointment at Ruinart, a champagne house, as reason for appearing in a handsome shirt, and was rallied upon it. He had in fact agreed with the house that a proposal should pass under the name of an “extra tasting,” among the crayères: chalk galleries sunk far below the earth.
As they were being escorted down to this extra tasting, and before she had any notion what it was, Melissa’s mind was occupied by a single question: had Jimmy warned her friend and her husband of it, the pair being engaged to dine with them that evening? Reason, it seemed, was in command. But the appearance lasted only as long as her ignorance, and her ignorance lasted all the way down and until the moment Jimmy went down on one knee. Then the worry left her entirely. He proposed; she said yes. Reason, so busy about the dinner, found it had nothing to add, and resumed its proper station.
The house presented them with a bottle, which they opened there in the cellar, the two of them alone, and finished later at the apartment with her friend and her husband. The jokes about the shirt were never retracted, which proves that some propositions survive even the most decisive refutation. The celebration was afterwards renewed in the south, among Melissa’s family.
Section X. Of Pride and Humility, as Exhibited in Cancún
Being engaged, they determined upon children; and in 2025, with Lily’s arrival close at hand, they travelled to Cancún. Their lodging there was the prize of a silent auction held for charity, and it was dreadful. Pride kept each of them silent: neither would confess to the other how dreadful it was. Enquiry among the neighbouring establishments found them charming and moderate in price; the prize was given up as a loss, and they removed to an agreeable house upon the sands. The remainder of the journey was excellent, and the first hotel remains to this day a subject of mirth between them; from which I conclude that humility, admitted together, is a great deal pleasanter than pride endured apart.
In June 2025 they exchanged the East Village for Park Slope, in Brooklyn.
Section XI. Of the Conclusion to Be Drawn
Of any volume, I have said, we should ask: does it contain abstract reasoning concerning quantity or number, or experimental reasoning concerning matter of fact? If neither, commit it to the flames. The present account contains a little of the first, in the concert register, and nothing but the second. It is spared.
I have demonstrated nothing; matters of fact admit of no demonstration. I say only that the observations are numerous, the conjunction constant, and the exceptions none, and that a wise man proportions his belief to the evidence. The evidence is that they will be married on 19 June 2027, at Miolan Provence, Le Cannet-des-Maures, thirty minutes or so from Draguignan, the town of Melissa’s girlhood. The future cannot be known with certainty; but upon so long an experience it would be unreasonable not to expect it, and I advise the reader to proportion his travel arrangements accordingly.
June 19, 2027 · Miolan, Provence