In the manner of

Friedrich Nietzsche


Ecce amantes: behold the lovers! Seeing that before long we must say the gravest Yes that can be asked of two people, it seems indispensable to us to say who we are. Hear us!

But first, an experiment. Suppose that one night a demon crept into our apartment in Park Slope and said: “This life, as you have lived it, you will have to live once more, and innumerable times more: every empty plane, every poncho you could not find, every disputed hand of cards, and that hotel.” Would we gnash our teeth and curse the demon? Or would we answer: “Never have we heard anything more divine”? Judge for yourselves.

Why We Met So Late

Melissa grew up in Draguignan, in the Var, under a sun that does not negotiate; then London kept her for twelve years. Jimmy came from Indianapolis, which is to say from the plain, and went to London to study: eighteen months as that creature who believes he is studying while life studies him. Eighteen months under the same grey sky, and not once did their paths cross. Rejoice! What arrives too early is spoiled.

Fate preferred New York: an evening given over to the ’80s at Le Poisson Rouge, a music venue, and a mutual friend to make the introduction. Call it chance, if you like: chance is merely fate in a good mood. Melissa was in New York only as a guest; her home was still London.

Jimmy’s memory of that night is, let us say, impressionistic. Melissa remembers it. The animal that forgets is happy, a certain philosopher once wrote. But a love needs both organs: one who forgets, so as to be happy, and one who remembers, so as to be right.

Why Jimmy Keeps Such Good Records

Since 2019 Jimmy has maintained a database of every concert he attends. Without music, life would be an error; without a spreadsheet, music would be a rumour. Melissa’s name recurs in it upwards of forty times, and climbs toward the summit.

And the first time her name appears? Le Poisson Rouge, again. Not the ’80s evening, which predates the archive, but a later show, in the same room. Do you hear it? The same place, returning. Thus begins the eternal recurrence: modestly, with a ticket.

Why Jimmy Is So Brave

Then the borders shut, like eyelids. America refused Melissa entry. Very well: then Jimmy would go out. Every crossing was his, eastward, always eastward, to London, on planes where a man could choose his row as a hermit chooses his mountain. Zarathustra went up into solitude for ten years; Jimmy went up into it one transatlantic flight at a time. What does not keep us apart makes us stronger.

Why Midnight Is Also Noon

Summer 2021. One country on earth had entry rules that would admit us both: Iceland. There the music held us out of doors till two, and at two the sun had still not set. “Midnight is also noon!” said Zarathustra, and we had taken it for a figure of speech. In Iceland it is a matter of latitude.

Why Melissa Is So Wise

In the autumn of 2021, Melissa came to New York. Mark the grammar: not “thought about”, not “hoped to”, not “would someday”. Came. The weak wish; the strong arrive. The will to power fits inside a single verb, and she conjugated it.

Beyond Victory and Defeat

October 2021, Santa Clara: the Indianapolis Colts against the San Francisco 49ers. Jimmy for the Colts, as befits a son of Indiana. Melissa for the 49ers, by right of an uncle in the Bay Area, a region she knows from her own stays; and let it be recorded, against every prejudice of the herd, that this Provençale understands the American game better than most of its natives.

The heavens sent an “atmospheric river”. Ponchos were scarce; rain was not. We were soaked to the soul. As for the result: we stand beyond winning and losing. Whoever asks who won has understood nothing, and will be told nothing.

On the Genealogy of a Ruling

In Jimmy’s family, Euchre has been played for as long as there has been a family: a card game of the American Midwest. In Melissa’s, Belote. To her, Euchre is Belote for the last man: comfortable, easy, the danger taken out.

Once, across the table from Jimmy’s parents, she contested a hand. The quarrel went up to a higher court, Jimmy’s brother, before whom the parties appeared without names, that he might judge impartially. The court recognised every litigant at a glance, and ruled all the same. Its verdict went against Melissa. Here, in miniature, is the whole genealogy of morals: there are no facts, only interpretations, and the interpretation of the bench is final.

Why Jimmy Has No Faith in Grammar

“I fear we are not rid of God because we still have faith in grammar.” Jimmy has no such faith, and is therefore free. Before proposing, he called Melissa’s parents by video to ask, in approximate French, for their blessing, glancing at a sheet kept just out of frame, on which he had gathered vocabulary and turns of phrase for every eventuality. He spoke. They answered with an emphatic yes.

Triumph! Jimmy stood upon the summit, and the eagle and the serpent circled overhead.

Only later did he learn the truth: his words had never reached them. They had read the question in the face on the screen, not in the sentence, and given their yes to what they had divined. He took it hard, against himself. We do not. Consider: a yes that needs no grammar is the purest yes there is.

Why One Must Go Down

July 2024, France, Champagne. Melissa’s best friend since the innocence of childhood came with her husband, and for the first time we met their daughter. Jimmy proclaimed an appointment at Ruinart, the champagne house, and made of it a pretext for a fine shirt. The couple mocked the shirt. Let them mock! The man who dresses above the occasion already knows what the occasion is.

For Jimmy had conspired with the people of Ruinart to dress his proposal up as one more tasting, a supplementary one, down among the crayères: chalk galleries far beneath the earth. “Thus began Zarathustra’s going-under”: one must descend before one may ask the highest question. Jimmy’s favourite book is The Count of Monte Cristo; he had always known that what matters happens underground, and comes back up transfigured.

As we were being led down to this supplementary tasting, Melissa, knowing nothing, had a single concern, and it does her honour: had Jimmy warned her oldest friend and that friend’s husband? Dinner with them was waiting! Such is the noble soul: on the threshold of its destiny, it thinks of its friends’ dinner.

The worry went down with her, step by step, and held fast until the moment Jimmy sank to one knee. Only then did she understand, and it fell from her like a cloak. He asked. She said yes. Here the philosopher sets down his hammer.

Ruinart gave us a bottle, and we opened it there beneath the earth, the two of us alone. We finished it later, in the daylight, at the apartment, with her childhood friend and her husband. The shirt jokes were never retracted, nor should they be: a true joke, like a true vow, is not taken back. Afterwards, the Midi, and a celebration with Melissa’s family.

Amor Fati

After the engagement we resolved to become more than two. In 2025, on the eve of Lily, we flew to Cancún. Our first hotel had been our “victory” in a silent auction held for a good cause. It was dreadful. And now a spectacle worthy of the gods: each of us resolved to suffer in silence, rather than confess to the other the full horror of the place. Two heroes, each enduring for the other’s sake a suffering the other was enduring for theirs!

At last we surveyed the neighbouring hotels: charming, every one, and the price no tragedy. We let the prize go and crossed over to a delightful hotel on the sand, and from then on the journey was splendid. The formula for greatness in a human being is amor fati: not merely to bear what is necessary, but to love it. We love that first hotel now. We laugh about it still. From a distance.

Why We Are a Destiny

Lily arrived in 2025. That June we left the East Village for Park Slope, in Brooklyn: a revaluation of all boroughs.

And now the demon’s question, once more. Every empty plane, the sun that would not set, the poncho we could not find, the hand of cards lost on appeal, the blessing nobody understood, the shirt, that hotel: all of it again, in the same order, forever? Was that love? Well then! Once more!

On 19 June 2027, at Miolan Provence, Le Cannet-des-Maures, deep in the Var, thirty minutes from Draguignan and the streets of Melissa’s childhood, we shall say the great Yes: the yes that says yes to everything that came before it.

Have we been understood? Indianapolis and Draguignan, at last on the same side.


← Choose another narrator

June 19, 2027 · Miolan, Provence