In the manner of

F. Scott Fitzgerald


I

At two o’clock on a summer morning in 2021, the sky over Iceland was still light, and Melissa and Jimmy, who had stayed out late for the live music, came out into it as into a room where someone had forgotten to put out the lamps. Nothing had prepared them for a night that simply declined to fall. They had come because Iceland, alone among the nations of the earth, would admit the two of them together at its border, and it seemed, that pale and endless evening, as if the whole island had stayed up on purpose, out of courtesy, to see how things would turn out between them.

II

There is a kind of history that is made mostly of near-misses. Melissa was a girl of Draguignan, in the hills of the Var, and had gone to London and stayed twelve years, long enough for the city to become hers. Jimmy came from Indianapolis, from the flat, generous heart of the country, and spent a student’s eighteen months in London, with the vague and expensive hopefulness of students everywhere. They lived in the same city, under the same rain, and they never met; it was as if London, which keeps a great many secrets, had decided to leave this one for somebody else to tell.

Somebody else turned out to be New York. She was a visitor there, nothing more — London was still where she lived — and a mutual friend brought her downtown to Le Poisson Rouge on an evening devoted to the songs of the nineteen-eighties, and there Jimmy met her. Melissa remembers that night precisely, the way one remembers the first page of a book one is going to go on reading. Jimmy remembers it the way one remembers the best parties: as a happy blur, gold at the edges, out of which a single face comes forward and stays. Of that face, at least, he has always been quite sure.

III

Then there was the ocean, which in those years grew wider than it had any right to be. For a while the borders of the world swung shut like the doors of a great house after the guests have gone, and America, for reasons of its own, had closed its door to her; so the crossings were all his. He flew to London among long rows of vacant seats, on planes that carried almost no one but himself and his reason for going, and there was something in it at once lonely and extravagant, like a man who buys out a theatre to watch a single performer.

When autumn came in 2021, Melissa moved her life to New York, and the ocean, which had been the thing between them, became the thing they had crossed.

That October they went out to Santa Clara to see the Colts of Indianapolis meet the 49ers of San Francisco. Jimmy was for the Colts, as a man from Indianapolis must be; Melissa was for the 49ers, by way of an uncle out by San Francisco Bay, whose country she had come to know, and she understood the game better than most of the Americans around her. Then the sky opened — an “atmospheric river,” the forecasters called it — and there were not nearly enough ponchos in California. They were soaked through, gloriously, and of the score I shall say nothing, for it is the only thing about that day that does not matter.

IV

Since 2019 Jimmy has kept a ledger of his concerts, for he is a romantic with bookkeeping, which is the most dangerous kind. Her name runs through its pages upward of forty times. It begins, as it was bound to, at Le Poisson Rouge — though at a concert on some later night, not the night of the eighties — as though she had come back to the same room to make it official, and year by year she draws nearer the head of it, which is where, in most things, she has a way of ending up.

There were the cards, too. Jimmy’s family had always played Euchre, as families in the Midwest do; Melissa’s family played Belote; and to Melissa, Euchre was Belote with the music turned low. Once, with Jimmy’s parents for opponents, she took exception to the way a hand had gone, and the quarrel was carried to Jimmy’s brother as an anonymous case, the parties unnamed, in the interest of fairness. But a man does not fail to know his own family across a card table, whatever is kept from him, and he found against Melissa.

V

Before he proposed, Jimmy sought the blessing of Melissa’s parents over a video call, and he sought it in French — or in something that had set out to be French, assembled from a sheet of vocabulary, kept just out of frame, that he had drawn up beforehand for every turn the conversation might take. He spoke. They listened. And they said yes, emphatically, with a warmth that left no room for doubt, and Jimmy rang off feeling like a man who has crossed a frontier on forged papers and been waved through with a smile.

Not until afterwards did he learn that none of his sentences had reached them. They had simply guessed what a young man with that look on his face must be asking. He was privately ashamed of his French — he had wanted the words to carry it — but there is a kind of yes that has no need of the question, and that was the kind he had been given.

VI

In July of 2024 they went down into the earth. They were travelling in France, and in Champagne they were met by the friend Melissa had loved best since they were children, and by the man that friend had married; and that summer Jimmy and Melissa were introduced at last to their daughter. Jimmy had booked them into Ruinart, and he dressed for the occasion in a shirt of real distinction — a shirt with intentions — and their two companions mocked him for it without mercy.

He had arranged everything with the house beforehand. There was to be, the staff announced, an “extra tasting,” and Melissa and Jimmy were led away, step after step, down into the old chalk cellars the French call crayères, which run far beneath the town, where the air is cool and the light is the colour of candle wax.

And it was there, on the stairs and in the long corridors, being escorted ever deeper, that Melissa began to worry. Had Jimmy said a word of any of this to her friend and her friend’s husband? There was a dinner waiting, and the pair of them would be at it. It would be rude; they would be late — and the worry went with her all the way down, along the corridors and into the place they were being taken, and it stayed with her until the moment Jimmy went down on one knee, when it went out of her all at once, like a candle blown out because no one needs it any more.

He asked. She said yes. Somewhere far above them the summer went on without them, and for a while neither of them cared to go back up into it.

The house gave them a bottle, and they opened it there in the cellar, the two of them alone, and finished it later at the apartment with her friend and her friend’s husband, after a lovely dinner; and the jokes about the shirt, which had been made in ignorance, were not withdrawn in the light of knowledge. They never have been. Afterwards they went south, to Melissa’s people, to a celebration with the whole warm weight of the Var behind it.

VII

After that they resolved, the two of them, that there should be a family. In 2025, with Lily due before long, they flew to Cancún, to a hotel that a charity’s silent bidding had awarded them — the sort of prize that sounds, in the bidding, like a small fortune, and turns out, on arrival, to be a test of character. It was awful. Each of them, out of tenderness, tried to bear it so as not to be the first to say so, and for a while they went on being brave at each other. At last they made inquiries along the shore, found the places round about charming and costing far less than they had feared, gave up their prize for lost, and carried themselves off to a lovely hotel on the sand, where the holiday became everything it had been meant to be. The first hotel survives only as a joke between them, and it is the only thing it was ever good for.

Lily was born that year, and in June the East Village gave them up to Park Slope, across the river.

VIII

And now there is to be a wedding. On the nineteenth of June, 2027, at Miolan Provence, at Le Cannet-des-Maures, half an hour or so from the Draguignan of Melissa’s girlhood, the two strangers of London will be married. Everything that kept them apart — the city that would not introduce them, the ocean, the shut doors of the world — has been crossed, one way and then the other, and there is no distance left to close. So they beat on, boats with the current for once, borne not back into the past but forward, at last, into harbour.


← Choose another narrator

June 19, 2027 · Miolan, Provence